Rick’s Quick Takes for Spring

For your consideration, recent releases from the worlds of prog, jazz, folk, country and marvelously unclassifiable music. As usual, purchase links are embedded in the artist/title listing, with streaming previews below the review.

Can, Live in Paris 1973: Another immensely enjoyable archive release from the guys who sent krautrock into orbit with a winning combination of tight grooves and freeform jamming. The fresh angle this time around is the presence of late vocalist Damo Suzuki; locking in with Jaki Liebezeit’s propulsive percussion, the throbbing bass of Holger Czukay, and Michael Karoli and Irwin Schmidt’s guitar/keyboard interplay, Suzuki burbles, banters, bickers – a daffy, devious jester who pulls improvised melody and lyric from thin air as he goes along. Oh, and forget about sounding “just like the records” – studio tracks “One More Night” and “Spoon” are touched on to kick off the jams, then abandoned or deepened, stretched like taffy to the point of sonic hypnosis, mannnn . . . Five gripping examples of Can’s live prowess; whether they could actually stop time or not (it may have been the psychedelics), these ninety minutes of unbridled creativity go by in a flash.

The Bill Fay Group, Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow: Ignored in the late 1960s and early 70s, British singer-songwriter Fay achieved cult favorite status after Wilco covered his hymnic “Be Not So Fearful” in the wake of 9/11. Utterly unlike the manneristic Dylan-meets-Kinks pop of his debut or the bleak rock crunch of 1971’s lost classic Time of the Last Persecution (both well worth seeking out), these vibrant demos from 1977 capture the gentle Christian mysticism at the heart of Fay’s songs, executed with grace and empathy by the three-piece Acme Quartet (?). The multiple versions of meditations like “Strange Stairway”, “Isles of Sleep” and “Life” radiate understated grace and power, foregoing apocalyptic panic to embrace simple, jubilant confessions of faith (“So that the world might believe/That Life has risen/That Life has conquered”). Prayers and hypnotic invocations that invite and welcome without rancor or hectoring, couched in song that’s timeless yet vividly in the moment.

Sierra Ferrell, Trail of Flowers: Widescreen mountain music for the anxious generation, this went straight to my 2024 Favorites list. In West Virginia native Ferrell’s sure grasp, her second album mounts to melodramatic heights on the wings of old time country. Ferrell’s sly, witty songwriting whiplashes between Americana subgenres to perfection; her opening run of originals – yearning road dog anthem “American Dreaming”, cautionary honky-tonk stomp “Dollar Bill Bar”, giddy fiddle reel “Fox Hunt”, and string-swathed heartbreaker “Wish You Well” left me astonished in the wake of their range and breadth. There isn’t a dud track here (check out jaunty Latin-tinged romp “Why Haven’t You Loved Me Yet”, murder ballad “Rosemary”, hybrid gospel/love song “Lighthouse” – oh heck, all of ’em); when you add in Ferrell’s beguiling voice (spanning the spectrum of twang from Janis Joplin to Dolly Parton and all points between) and gutsy fiddle work, plus producer Eddie Spear’s rich gothic ambience, the result is thoroughly winning. Believe the hype – if anybody can save country music from Greater Nashville’s ongoing torrent of processed pop, artists like Sierra Ferrell and Charley Crockett (both playing my local outdoor amphitheater this summer) are your best bet.

Vijay Iyer, Compassion: Building on the near-telepathic teamwork they established on 2021’s Uneasy (one of my faves from that year), pianist Iyer, bassist Linda May Han Oh and drummer Tyshawn Sorey come out swinging with this full-on follow-up. The impressionistic title tune shimmers into focus, with the trio relying on space and silence as much as sound; a luscious take on Stevie Wonder’s “Overjoyed” doubles as a tribute to Chick Corea, inspired by Iyer’s opportunity to play the late legend’s own piano. Whether on the angular, driving “Ghostrumental” or the rugged throwback blues “It Goes”, Oh pulls gorgeous melodies out of the air, Sorey whips up a seething percussive stew even as he grooves, and Iyer stirs in one heady, pensive idea after another. Iyer characterizes the music as “a reminder, an assurance, a plea, and perhaps an inspiration – to find each other in this together”; it’s a tribute to these exceptional musicians that, with what seems like maximum grace and minimum sweat, Compassion tangibly conjures up the empathy it advocates in sound.

Joel Ross, nublues: Chicago-born vibraphonist Ross impressed me to no end when I caught him live as part of the Blue Note 85th-Anniversary All-Star Band this past January. His fourth album is of a piece with his previous three: a soundworld of abstract yet delightfully contemplative jazz, soaked in the blues, always tumbling and turning with a non-stop flow of invention. Ross’ interaction with young saxophone lion Immanuel Wilkins (also an All-Star), Jeremy Corren on piano and bass/drums duo Kanoa Mendenhall and Jeremy Corren are the secret sauce at the music’s heart, whether putting their own spin on Thelonious Monk’s “Evidence” or John Coltrane’s “Equinox” and “Central Park West”, conjuring the title track from thin air – Mendenhall shines on bowed bass here – or building “Bach (God the Father in Eternity)” into a steamrolling surge of gospel-soaked eloquence. It’s like crashing a conversation already in progress and discovering you were invited all along.

SiX by SiX, Beyond Shadowland: Robert Berry, Ian Crichton and Nigel Glockler hit hard and strong, blasting past Difficult Second Album Syndrome to craft a wild and wooly extension of their first-rate debut. Sonically, this one comes across hotter and crunchier, as multi-instrumentalist Berry corrals Crichton’s hypercreative guitar licks into decidedly unconventional song structures, then layers in heaping helpings of lyrical positivity, while Glockler lays down rock solid percussive foundations. The result is a record that gets stronger as it goes, with head-turning surprises that stack up thick and fast: the acoustic-based sci-fi narrative “Obiliex”, the slashing, tribally funky “Titans”, the fuzz-toned flutter of “Sympathize” and, in “One Step”, an epic that progresses from yearning balladry through a proggy midsection to a hip-hop shuffle that works! Add in the relatively straight-up singles “Arms of a Word” and “The Mission” and you have a sophomore effort that oozes both mass appeal and maximum creativity. Check out the new Progarchy interview with Robert Berry here.

The Tangent, To Follow Polaris (released May 10): On which Andy Tillison takes off the gloves. Playing all the instruments himself (the album’s labeled “Tangent for one”) with style and panache, Tillison sails confidently through textures ranging from glitchy electronica to vintage soul and funk, with generous lashings of his trademark organ and synthesizer throughout. Kaleidoscopic overture/mission statement “The North Sky” lays down Tillison’s lyrical marker on graspable truth; brooding ballad-of-the-algorithm “A Like in the Darkness” paints a genuinely creepy portrait of online life; “The Fine Line” muses on the commodification of journalism, “destroy[ing] the world to sell the story”. Then on “The Anachronism”, Andy lets it rip – a furious jeremiad calling out both the ineffectual monocracy that’s lost its grip on events and the self-absorbed masses who watch it all happen on their phones. The whole thing builds to a crashing, anarchic climax – only to return to Tillison’s beginning, “follow[ing] the North Star/(When all around me seems to be going South)”. Be warned: something Tillison sings on this audacious, accomplished effort will probably cheese you off – but only because, in a world of grinning provocateurs, shameless attention whores and cynical game players, he’s a genuine idealist, with no other agenda than speaking his mind and wondering why we can’t have a better world.

Transatlantic, Morsefest 2022: The Absolute Whirlwind: Or should this be subtitled, “More Never Is Enough . . . Yet Again, Still”? Transatlantic’s second live set off the back of 2022’s The Absolute Universe, this five-CD, two-BluRay set certainly doesn’t skimp on the quantity. There’s five hours of music here from two consecutive nights: the twin album-length epics that provide the release’s title, three elongated ballads, a side-long Procol Harum cover, and bits and bobs of five more extended extravaganzas from the back catalog. It’s not all gravy; there are brief instants where the energy flags and, as Neal Morse and Roine Stolt strain to sing the high notes, I’m reminded that it’s been 25 years since this supergroup first crashed into the prog world’s consciousness. But these are far outnumbered by the moments where Morse, Stolt, Pete Trewavas, Mike Portnoy and “fifth Transatlantic” Ted Leonard fire up the afterburners and launch into startlingly tight ensemble passages, awe-inspiring solos, pin-sharp vocal counterpoint (often backed up by a real choir), dizzying transitions and over-the-top, orchestrally augmented climaxes. Too much of a good thing? It’s possible – but, with the recent news that Portnoy’s resumed the drum chair in Dream Theater, Transatlantic isn’t a good thing to be taken for granted.

— Rick Krueger

SiX by SiX’s Robert Berry: The 2024 Progarchy Interview

Two years after their fine debut album, SiX by SiX — Saga guitarist Ian Crichton, Saxon drummer Nigel Glockler and veteran vocalist/bassist/keyboardist/arranger Robert Berry — release their sophomore effort Beyond Shadowland on April 26th. The 11 new tracks hit hard and strong, stretching out in an eclectic variety of directions but always stuffed full of upbeat lyrics, killer melodic hooks, thrillingly crunchy guitar work, and tough, grounded percussive grooves.

What with the pre-release singles “The Arms of a Word” and “Obiliex” – the pronunciation of the latter somehow becoming a running gag below) already out in the wild, Robert Berry – who I first interviewed in 2022 – was ready and eager to talk about the band’s working process, their hopes for the new album, and their coalescing plans for live work! (One confirmed live date was announced after our time together, at New Jersey’s annual ProgStock festival in October.) As before, Berry proved gracious, genial, and genuinely interested in my reactions to SiX by SiX’s latest material. The video of this interview is right below, with a transcript plus the videos of the singles following the jump.

Continue reading “SiX by SiX’s Robert Berry: The 2024 Progarchy Interview”

BEAT (Belew, Vai, Levin, Carey) Tour 1980s King Crimson This Fall — Full Details Below

As Kevin McCormick posted two weeks ago, Adrian Belew & Tony Levin of King Crimson will be performing that band’s innovative 1980s repertoire live with pioneering shred guitarist Steve Vai (Frank Zappa, David Lee Roth, G3) and drummer Danny Carey (Tool). More than 40 US/Canada dates (listed below and at www.beat-tour.com) have been announced; a presale begins April 2nd at 12 noon EDT (password BEATTOUR), with sales to the general public starting April 5th.

To say I’m stoked for this tour is an understatement! I became a fan of all things associated with King Crimson founder Robert Fripp after hearing him live at a local record store in 1979,then devouring his articles about the creative process and the travails of the music business in Musician magazine. So I was primed when Fripp, Belew, Levin and drummer Bill Bruford launched a re-envisioned KC with 1981’s breakthrough album Discipline. In addition to the striking use of cutting-edge tech like Simmons electronic drums and Roland guitar synthesizers (along with a New Wave sense of texture and space), I loved how all four players were constantly interweaving; there was no real precedent for the sound in rock or even prog, but Balinese gamelan music, classical minimalists like Steve Reich & Philip Glass, and some of Talking Heads’ contemporaneous experiments came to mind. This was just the noise for a heady, more than slightly pretentious listener like me!

1982’s Beat turned out to be my favorite of the albums the band released, but I didn’t see the mighty Crim live until the Three of a Perfect Pair tour in the summer of 1984 – by which time they had throughly assimilated their new music and stomped audiences flat with it! It was the first of 10 times I heard Crimson in concert over the decades, and still it’s vividly memorable.

Shortly afterward, Fripp put Crimson on one of the band’s numerous indefinite pauses, but Belew has always had a soft spot for this music, even publishing an online appeal to Fripp, Levin & Bruford for a 30th-anniversary reunion in 2011. This only happened in truncated form: Belew’s Power Trio hooked up with Levin’s Stick Men for a series of Two of A Perfect Trio dates (I caught the Detroit stop of the tour late that year) eventually becoming the Crimson ProjeKct and opening for Dream Theater on a lengthly tour.

And while I absolutely adore Fripp’s Belew-less version of KC that ran from 2014 to 2021 (see my reviews here, here and here), I’m no less ready to lose it for a Fripp-less take on this classical material like BEAT. Given Vai & Carey’s impeccable credentials, this should be some show.

— Rick Krueger

BEAT Tour dates:

  • 9/12 SAN JOSE, CA @ SAN JOSE CIVIC
  • 9/13 NAPA, CA @ BLUE NOTE SUMMER SESSIONS at MERITAGE RESORT
  • 9/14 LOS ANGELES, CA @ THE UNITED THEATER on BROADWAY
  • 9/15 ANAHEIM, CA @ CITY NATIONAL GROVE of ANAHEIM
  • 9/17 SAN DIEGO, CA @ HUMPHREY’S CONCERTS
  • 9/18 PHOENIX, AZ @ CELEBRITY THEATRE
  • 9/20 AUSTIN, TX @ THE PARAMOUNT THEATRE
  • 9/21 HOUSTON, TX @ BAYOUS MUSIC CENTRE
  • 9/22 DALLAS, TX @ MAJESTIC THEATRE
  • 9/24 ATLANTA, GA @ THE EASTERN
  • 9/26 FORT LAUDERDALE, FL @ THE PARKER
  • 9/27 ORLANDO, FL @ HARD ROCK LIVE
  • 9/28 CLEARWATER, FL @ RUTH ECKERD HALL
  • 9/29 CHARLESTON, SC @ CHARLESTON MUSIC HALL
  • 10/01 CHARLOTTE, NC @ KNIGHT THEATER
  • 10/02 DURHAM, NC @ CAROLINA THEATRE of DURHAM / FLETCHER HALL
  • 10/04 WASHINGTON, DC @ WARNER THEATRE
  • 10/05 NEW YORK, NY @ BEACON THEATRE
  • 10/06 GLENSIDE, PA @ KESWICK THEATRE
  • 10/08 RICHMOND, VA @ CARPENTER THEATER in DOMINION ENERGY CENTER
  • 10/09 RED BANK, NJ @ COUNT BASIE CENTER
  • 10/11 BOSTON, MA @ SHUBERT THEATRE
  • 10/12 HAMPTON BEACH, NH @ HAMPTON BEACH CASINO BALLROOM
  • 10/14 HALIFAX, NS @ REBECCA COHEN AUDITORIUM
  • 10/15 MONCTON, NB @ CASINO NEW BRUNSWICK
  • 10/17 MONTREAL, QC @ THEATRE MAISONNEUVE
  • 10/18 TORONTO, ON @ MASSEY HALL
  • 10/19 ROCHESTER, NY @ KODAK CENTER
  • 10/21 ALBANY, NY @ THE EGG
  • 10/22 GREENSBURG, PA @ PALACE THEATRE
  • 10/23 READING, PA @ SANTANDER PERFORMING ARTS CENTER
  • 10/25 CLEVELAND, OH @ AGORA THEATRE
  • 10/26 CINCINNNATI, OH @ TAFT THEATRE
  • 10/27 ROYAL OAK, MI @ ROYAL OAK MUSIC THEATRE
  • 10/28 NASHVILLE, TN @ RYMAN AUDITORIUM
  • 10/30 INDIANAPOLIS, IN @ MURAT THEATRE
  • 11/01 CHICAGO, IL @ COPERNICUS CENTER
  • 11/02 MILWAUKEE, WI @ PABST THEATRE
  • 11/03 MADISON, WI @ ORPHEUM THEATER
  • 11/04 MINNEAPOLIS, MN @ STATE THEATRE
  • 11/06 DENVER, CO @ PARAMOUNT THEATRE
  • 11/08 LAS VEGAS, NV @ THE THEATER at VIRGIN HOTEL

Happy Easter

Happy Easter. Someone at Progarchy usually posts some version of Marillion’s “Easter” every year, but this year it seems more fitting than ever. The lyrics of the song refer to The Troubles Ireland experienced for much of the second half of the twentieth century, and the title and lyrics also reference William Butler Yeats’ poem, “Easter, 1916,” about the 1916 Irish rebellion. In troubled times like these, with violent bloody wars popping up all over threatening to draw us back into darker times, Marillion’s “Easter” rings out truer than ever:

What will you do?
Make a stone of your heart?
Will you set things right
When you tear them apart?
Will you sleep at night
With the plough and the stars alight?

In Concert: With Steve Hackett, It’s All Highlights

Steve Hackett: Genesis Revisited – Foxtrot at Fifty + Hackett Highlights, The State Theatre, Kalamazoo Michigan, March 23, 2024.

Yet again, another Progarchist beat me to reviewing Steve Hackett’s current tour — this time by three months! I can’t complain, though; Connor’s November review and last fall’s CD/BluRay release convinced me to catch Hackett in concert for the fifth time since he resumed stateside touring in 2013. And I’d say this most recent gig — played to over 1500 fans that packed a historic downtown theatre in Gibson Guitars’ original hometown — was the best of the five.

As I mentioned the last time Hackett played West Michigan, his current band is both precision tooled and breathtakingly daring. Craig Blundell’s fleet, thundering drums propel the music forward at a thrilling pace (no click tracks here!); bassist Jonas Reingold anchors the low end with nimble melodic licks and a terrific sense of interplay; self-effacing keyboardist Roger King genuinely deserves the “one-man orchestra” label. The opening blast from Hackett’s brand-new album The Circus and the Nightwhale — dramatic overture “People of the Smoke”, giddy tarantella “Circo Inferno”, classically-tinged ballad “These Passing Clouds” — showed their remarkable range, while Rob Townsend’s woodwinds and Hackett’s lead guitar took off from that solid musical foundation with tasty, direct themes and hyperspeed unison lines.

While the initial set of “Hackett Highlights” contained plenty of reliable crowd-pleasers, my favorite was the deep cut “Camino Royale”. A funky Reingold solo spot merged into a duet with Blundell, suddenly crashing into the bold opening riff; then an extended midsection gave Townsend space to develop his most compelling solo of the night, followed by Hackett’s wildest playing — squeezing out metallic sparks one moment, launching keening, heart-piercing sustains the next.

Still, let’s face it: Hackett wouldn’t have his current touring career if he hadn’t been fervently waving the “Genesis Revisited” banner for the last eleven years. And it was the classic 1972 Genesis album Foxtrot that this audience had come to hear.

Continue reading “In Concert: With Steve Hackett, It’s All Highlights”

BEAT: Super Group forming to perform music from the King Crimson catalogue

In an unexpected turn of events, a new supergroup has been formed. It’s a quartet featuring some of the most impressive musicians today — Steve Vai, Adrian Belew, Tony Levin, and Tool drummer Danny Carey. Called Beat, the band will play King Crimson music and they’ve been announced by none other than the King Crimson mastermind Robert Fripp. Read more….Easily one of the most mind-blowing lineups you can ever come up with.

The Bardic Depths, What We Really Like in Stories (2024)

“The third time’s the charm.”

Is it?

Strangeness and charm? “A drug for angels?”

Yes, charm, but only a bit of strangeness; I’ll get to that.  To charm means “to delight” or “to enchant.”  When we say “the third time’s the charm,” does this imply that the first and second times were lacking?  Often, perhaps, but not this time.  If you’ll indulge me for a moment, allowing that every time so far has been “the charm,” then harken, friends…

The third album from The Bardic Depths, What We Really Like in Stories (release date March 7th, 2024) is a charm that brings a most welcome enchantment to what many of us are experiencing as dark times.  With fewer “guests” than before, the chemistry between the four band members (Dave Bandana, Gareth Cole, Peter Jones, and Tim Gehrt) and their lyricist (Bradley Birzer) is even more palpable here than it was on Promises of Hope. Every one of the four group members shines here, but not by trying to outdo what they have done before.  Rather, they shine (no surprise) by passionately devoting their artistry to bringing life and breath to Birzer’s concept, which is a set of songs paying tribute to several great storytellers (Tolkien and Lewis, Ray Bradbury, Alan Moore, Willa Cather, Robert E. Howard, and Walter M. Miller).

And here is the strangeness:  Unlike the first two TBD albums, despite the title’s direct reference to stories, there really are no stories here!  No overall story arc, and nothing will strike the listener as a narrative in any of the songs!  Well, not directly, anyway. Of course there are references to stories, hints of narratives we know, allusions to what the featured authors have written. But the point this time is not to tell or embody the stories. Rather than being story or stories, the album is about storytellers. So as my students have been saying in recent years, it’s “meta.” The point is to focus on the storytellers, to bring their lives to our awareness, to sing a trajectory for each, that so many of us have already followed before. This song cycle often beautifully evokes a sort of atmosphere that pervades a work or works of an author, and that readers will find at least somewhat familiar.  It is like being drawn into aural spaces that give honor to the authors by being a place where we can dwell with them (which is not to be confused with “being reminded” of them).

The phenomenon I have in mind is well understood by Rob Birnholz, who created an amazing video for the album’s first single, “You’ve Written Poetry, My Boy,” which is for Ray Bradbury.  Having read and enjoyed a great deal of Bradbury’s work over the years, I was already instantly taken with the song when I first heard it. Birnholz’s video, however, made the atmosphere of the song even more vivid and encompassing.

Another standout track for me, both lyrically and musically, is “Vendetta” (for Alan Moore). It especially caught my attention because I have lately returned to reading the work of French sociologist and theologian Jacques Ellul (1912-1994). Ellul is famous for his work on technology in modern societies. But in his original French, he actually emphasizes the broader concept of “la technique,” which is not the same as what English readers would think of as technology (and which is difficult to capture clearly in English translation). Technique is defined by Ellul as “the totality of methods rationally arrived at and having absolute efficiency (for a given stage of development) in every field of human activity” (The Technological Society, 1954). It names a system of rational means that increasingly dominates our lives in modern society, constituting a totalizing way of living where what is touted as freedom increasingly becomes a form of slavery. Technology, then, as Ellul understands it, is the discourse that accompanies the ubiquity of technique, which most often has the character of propaganda.

The disappointment and emptiness of “Vendetta” strikes me as precisely the disappointment and even despair that descends when it becomes clear that the promises of technology (in Ellul’s sense) are empty. What Ellul and Birzer have in common is that they find hope amid dystopian visions is Christian hope. But for Birzer, as was true for Promises of Hope, I think that it’s not a matter of pushing a particular theological agenda. It seems to me, rather, that what we can glimpse in What We Really Like in Stories is the possibility that stories, unlike technology and propaganda, might be a medium for hope.

I have singled out a couple of the songs, but on my third listen to the whole thing, I’m less inclined to name standouts and more inclined to rave about just how good this band is.  Every instrumentalist’s contribution seems to fall into place perfectly. The solos are just the right mixture of virtuosity and restraint. Both lead and harmony vocals are consistently lovely. (And I’m so glad that Rick Krueger’s awesome church organ makes an appearance!)  With Robin Armstrong’s production assistance on top of it all, the sound texture is, from beginning to end, irresistible! (See Kruekutt’s interview with TBD for the band’s perspective on how this all came about.)

What We Really Like in Stories at Bandcamp.

The Bardic Depths on Facebook.

Live at Last – Big Big Train Rock The USA (Sweetwater, 3/1/24)

Big Big Train, Live at Sweetwater, Fort Wayne, IN, March 1, 2024
Band: Alberto Bravin (lead vocals, keyboards, guitar), Nick D’Virgilio (drums, vocals), Oskar Holldorff (keyboards, backing vocals), Clare Lindley (violin, vocals, keyboards, guitar), Rikard Sjöblom (guitars, keyboards, vocals) and Gregory Spawton (bass, bass pedals, acoustic guitar/12-string), and Cade Gotthardt (trumpet, keyboards)
Setlist: Folklore, The Connection Plan, The First Rebreather, The Florentine, Summoned By Bells, Mead Hall in Winter, Telling the Bees, East Coast Racer, A Boy in Darkness, Love is the Light, Apollo
Encore: Victorian Brickwork

I didn’t think I would ever see the day, but there I was Friday evening sitting sixth row center at Big Big Train’s first ever live show in America. It’s been a long time coming – 11 years for me. I discovered Big Big Train back in 2013 while in college in Hillsdale, MI, less than an hour and a half from Sweetwater in Fort Wayne, Indiana. But for this show I drove 5 hours from Bowling Green, Kentucky, where I just moved from Saint Louis, MO last Monday. A wild week, to be sure, but I wasn’t about to miss this show.

After a moderately expensive visit to Hyde Brothers books in Fort Wayne (a must visit for fans of used books), I made it to a local restaurant for a dinner meetup with folks from the Big Big Train Facebook group. Friend and fellow Progarchy editor Rick Krueger kindly invited me (as I’m not on bookface), and he even bought me dinner. Thanks Rick! After that, the group emigrated to the Sweetwater campus, a beautiful building with an intimate auditorium that seats around 260 people. At that size, there probably isn’t a bad seat in the place.

The show was general admission, but I found a fantastic seat about two seats left of center in the sixth row. My only complaint with my choice was Rikard ended up blocking my view of Greg most of the show, but Greg made his presence clearly known on the low end. Sonically speaking, it was a fantastic seat. Overall this may have been the best sounding rock concert I’ve attended. The volume was perfect, and distortion was minimal. At times some of the keyboards were a little low in the mix (not Oskar’s, but the keyboards Alberto periodically played). Other than that, it sounded great – a testament to Rob Aubrey’s important role in this band. I don’t remember the last show where I didn’t have to wear ear plugs.

The show got off to a rousing start with a more accessible number in “Folklore,” which was followed up by a more recent accessible track with “The Connection Plan” off 2022’s “Welcome to the Planet.” The prog came into the station with “The First Rebreather,” a welcome throwback to 2012’s “English Electric: Part One.” The energetic pieces were a great warmup to the slower, more contemplative classic. I think First Rebreather may have been the first BBT song I ever heard, making it extra special to hear it live.

New lead vocalist Alberto Bravin was a fiery storm of energy from the opening notes of the show, running onto the stage and firing up the crowd from the get-go on “Folklore.” He continued this energy throughout the night, with a particularly fun trip through the aisles of the venue with Nick D’Virgilio as they sang a vocal duet on “The Florentine.”

The setlist was replete with long tracks, including “A Mead Hall in Winter,” “East Coast Racer” and encore “Victorian Brickwork.” The instrumental passages highlighted the talent of this band, particularly the tightness of stalwarts Greg Spawton, Nick D’Virgilio, and Rikard Sjöblom. Nick didn’t miss a beat all night, with his intricate drumming a joy to witness on the audience’s right side of the stage. Greg’s Rickenbacker boomed, but his bass pedals shook the building. Rikard really shined for me in this show. His guitar solos were excellent, along with his work on the Hammond organ. He was clearly having a blast, as he always seems to be on the band’s live Blu-Rays. Considering he was playing parts for two guitarists, it was all the more impressive. Alberto picked up an electric (and acoustic) guitar at points, but Rikard took the lion’s share of the work, and he performed flawlessly.

Nick and Rikard had a touching tribute to David Longdon with their acoustic version of “Telling the Bees,” with Nick on lead vocals, demonstrating how versatile everyone in this band is. The duet gave the rest of the band a chance for a quick bathroom break before returning to steam their way through “East Coast Racer.” The highlight of the track had to be Alberto’s astonishing “She flies.” He carried the note far longer than I expected, and it was a very moving moment. Also moving was “A Boy in Darkness,” an unexpected choice from English Electric. Overall those albums were well represented at this show.

They only played one song from the new album – “Love is the Light” – but they really shined with it. It was great hearing Alberto sing at his most natural, and the song tastefully blends accessible lyrics with subtle complexity in the music. Alberto was truly in his element on this track, showing what a natural performer he is. Even if his interactions with the audience between songs were a little awkward (due to the slight language barrier, I think), once the music is playing, all of that falls away and he shines.

“Apollo” was a treat as an instrumental, and when Alberto wasn’t playing something, he was running around the auditorium with a tambourine (which I overheard someone in line say they saw him buy in the Sweetwater store earlier that day) stirring up the enraptured audience.

Instead of leaving the stage and coming back out for an encore, the band merely asked if we wanted a final song. They asked us what we thought they’d play, and people shouted out some requests. “The Underfall Yard” was heard clearly, and one enthusiastic fan wanted deep cut “The Wide Open Sea.” Neither request was granted, the band giving us “Victorian Brickwork” instead. I don’t think anyone complained about that choice. A fine way to end the show.

As the band’s first show of the tour, there were a couple expected hiccups. They weren’t playing at full strength, and thus everyone had to contribute in multiple ways. I only picked up on two noticeable mistakes, and I’m not even going to bother identifying them here because everyone was so professional and carried on so well that it isn’t worth pointing it out. For music this complicated, you’d be justified in expecting more mistakes, but instead they played incredibly well. I told Oskar when I met him after the show that he played really well, and he had big shoes to fill playing Danny Manners’ parts. He pointed out that he was essentially playing the parts of three people since the live band is normally much larger! So yeah, they played great.

As they’ve done at past shows, the band made themselves available to the fans out in the lobby after the show. After my long wait at the merch desk to pick up the new album on CD/BR as well as the reissue of David Longdon’s Wild River on CD, I was able to wait in shorter lines to meet and get photos with several of the band members. I was especially excited to meet Greg. His art and his support are a huge reason behind Progarchy’s existence, and his music and lyrics have been a major intellectual and artistic influence for me for over a decade now. It was an honor to meet him, as well as the other members of the band. It’s so cool that they are willing to meet people after the show. I’m sure it’s tedious for them, but it’s cool for us as fans. They were all so kind.

I’d say Big Big Train’s first show in the US was a rousing success. Hopefully this short tour will be enough of a financial success for the band to warrant them coming back to America in the future – hopefully on a longer tour. I know I’d go see them again in a heartbeat.

In Concert: Big Big Train Build “A Mead Hall in America”

Big Big Train, Sweetwater Performance Theatre, Fort Wayne, Indiana – March 1, 2024

Four years ago this month, Big Big Train’s first North American tour was cancelled, a victim of the worldwide COVID pandemic. Just over 28 months ago, a more ambitious debut tour fell apart before it could even be announced, following the shocking death of BBT singer/songwriter/frontman David Longdon. Finally – finally! – last Friday night, nearly 250 fans (including me, my wife and fellow Progarchist Bryan Morey) packed a state of the art auditorium at the largest music retailer on the planet.

We waited as the announced start time ticked past. And waited some more. Really, how much suspense can BBT’s loyal Passengers – some fortified with sprouts, it’s true, but still – stand?

But all last-minute anxieties fell away as the international septet filed onstage, counted in and exploded into the opener “Folklore”. The audience launched into the singalong chants from the first – “Hey ho, so we go/We pass it on, we hand it down”, indeed – as new frontman Alberto Bravin ramped up into a kinetic dynamo, belting out the melody, prowling the length of the stage, stoking it all to a higher pitch. Meanwhile, the rest of the band dug into the song’s earthy folk-rock rhythm, constantly catching each other’s glances and grinning, as if to say, “can you believe we actually, finally get to do this?”

Rather than focus on their released-that-day effort The Likes of Us, Big Big Train generously gave us Statesiders what we’ve been wanting all these years — a bountiful cross-section of their back catalog from 2009’s game-changing The Underfall Yard through 2021’s Welcome to the Planet. And if the musical balance tipped ever so slightly toward the peak Anglophilia of the English Electric era, with “The First Rebreather” and “Summoned By Bells” as the set’s early landmarks, no one in the crowd seemed to be complaining.

At the back of the stage, keyboardist Oskar Holldorff and bassist/founder Gregory Spawton anchored the music, with Wakemanesque grand piano, sinewy Rickenbacker lines and booming bass pedals laying down track for free passage. To their right, freshly recruited trumpeter Cade Gotthardt covered BBT’s trademark brass parts, sometimes pivoting toward fusion-era Miles Davis fanfares and colors to fresh effect. Up front, Clare Lindley specialized in rippling, quicksilver violin licks; Rikard Sjöblom tackled his own fluid guitar parts plus absent guitarist David Foster’s riffs plus chunky, fiery organ work; and Nick D’Virgilio moved effortlessly from one off-center rhythm to the next, hands and feet awhirl with the rhythmic possibilities. Meanwhile, everyone but Spawton and Gotthardt contributed backing vocals; Bravin, Gotthardt and Lindley added orchestral keyboard pads as needed; and a 12-string guitar purchased at Sweetwater during rehearsals passed between Bravin, D’Virgilio, Lindley, Sjöblom and Spawton as if they’d gathered round a campfire. The cumulative effect kept the audience on the edge of their seats, giddy with the pace and eager for the next inevitable surprise.

Mirroring the onstage swirl of genre, color and texture, the band’s presentation never remained static. D’Virgilio joined Bravin front and center for their vocal duet on Grand Tour’s “The Florentine”, venturing into the audience for a second verse walkabout; on Grimspound’s “A Mead Hall in Winter” (the current tour’s namesake) Spawton stepped forward and gathered the mobile players for an accelerating jam that careened through metallic stops and starts. Out of that whirlwind came the gentlest moment of the night: D’Virgilio and Sjöblom’s tribute to Longdon. Their acoustic take on his “Telling the Bees” was utterly poignant – grief refracted through joy and gratitude, the audience eagerly picking up the chorus, everyone calling to memory the artistic gifts that their absent friend had shared so generously.

Then, the pealing piano chords that herald “East Coast Racer” — and suddenly any opening night jitters fell away from the band, any onstage fluffs no longer mattered. Big Big Train locked in with each other, ramping up the intensity; Bravin roared, purred and declaimed the narrative; the crowd entered the drama inherent in Spawton’s defining epic – more than the story of a train setting a land speed record, a evocation of the sweat and effort of the men behind the breakthrough. And as the audience joined in Bravin’s climactic cry – “And into history/And into legend/She flies” – the night came together in a sublime thrill of tension, release and catharsis.

From that point, an excellent show turned consistently great, as BBT sprinted for the finish line — Longdon’s grim chronicle “A Boy in Darkness”, Bravin’s delicate new ballad “Love Is the Light” and D’Virgilio’s exuberant instrumental “Apollo” chilled the blood, then plucked the heartstrings, then pumped up the adrenaline. Then, after a teasing Bravin invited the crowd to guess the encore, came “Victorian Brickwork” from The Underfall Yard. As Spawton’s doleful tale of familial regret and remorse unwound and the mist of intricate cross-rhythms cleared, Gotthardt launched into that elegiac trumpet coda — and grown men (including me) cried freely and with abandon.

What more is there to say about such an exciting, moving, thoroughly satisfying night? Big Big Train repaid their US audience’s longstanding devotion with interest, and the overwhelming atmosphere of happiness carried over to a relaxed after-show meet and greet. My advice: catch them in Boston (March 5) or Buffalo (March 6) if you can – and hope this mini-tour has sold well enough so that they can mount a return trip before their visas expire!


— Rick Krueger

Setlist:

  • Folklore
  • The Connection Plan
  • The First Rebreather
  • The Florentine
  • Summoned by Bells
  • A Mead Hall in Winter
  • Telling the Bees
  • East Coast Racer
  • A Boy in Darkness
  • Love Is the Light
  • Apollo
  • Victorian Brickwork

The Best Prog Bands You’ve Never Heard Of (Part Thirty-Seven): Sindelfingen

When it comes to obscure prog bands, these guys might just take first prize. Fifty years ago, four British chaps known collectively as Sindelfingen released their only complete studio album, the delightfully named Odgipig – but only 100 copies were made available. Thanks to the Internet, however, we now have regular access to a particularly rare gem such as this one.

Odgipig, although somewhat inconsistent in places, is a solid and even rather original debut. Unlike many of their prog contemporaries, Sindelfingen forwent the typical keyboard setup and opted instead for a glockenspiel (played superbly by Roger Woods), which lends the album a unique and pastoral sound a la Jethro Tull’s Songs from the Wood. This sound is shaped also by the presence of acoustic guitars and recorder (both played with finesse by Mark Letley), especially on “Today and Tomorrow” and “Perpetual Motion,” the former being, in my humble opinion, the strongest track on the album. Lead singer Richard Manktelow (who also plays guitar) and drummer Roger Thorn are no slouches themselves, however, in their respective roles. Manktelow’s vocals are easy on the ears and Thorn anchors a dependable rhythm section with Letley (who also plays bass; he’s the type of musician who might have been recruited by Gentle Giant).

Sindelfingen enjoyed a brief foray into the prog world before fading into obscurity, but we today can appreciate the little gem they left behind for us. Below is the original album along with some bonus tracks that are also worth a listen.